What is Constructive Discharge?

September 16, 2008

In some cases, courts will apply the doctrine of constructive discharge when your job conditions were so bad that you had no choice but to quit.  In appropriate cases, a court will apply employment laws as though you were discharged from employment.

As set forth in McGanty v. Staudenraus, 321 Or 535, 557 (1995), there are four (4) elements a former employee must establish to prove that s/he was constructively discharged:

  1. The employer intentionally created or maintained specified working conditions;
  2. The working conditions were so intolerable that a reasonable person would have resigned;
  3. The employer desired to cause the employee to leave or was certain s/he would leave;
  4. The employee left as a result of the working conditions.

In many cases, the question is whether the working conditions were “so intolerable” that a reasonable person would have resigned.  Courts have interpreted these elements numerous times and I will try to cover some of these decisions in later blog posts.

Leave a Comment